I am aware that this discussion took place earlier in the year, however, this happened tonight, and I'm still not clear if I made the right call or not?
5 people in the hand, flop comes 5H, KC and 3S, player 1, 2 check, player 3 bets heavy, player 4 folds, 5 calls and 1 & 2 fold.
Turn and river are irrelevant, as player 3 bet the turn, player 5 called as well as the river.
Now, when the hands were tabled, player 3 had a 5H in his hand, giving him 3 5's, but 2 of them were 5H's, and player 5 had 2 pair.
It was then that it was noted that there were 2 5H's in play, i made the call that the hand be split between remaining players, as player 3 said he didn't realize that it was the same card as he was holding, player 5 wanted the whole pot, and the other 3 players wanted their money back?
Was this the right call?
Or should everything have been given back to all players, including blinds?